Jeffro's Space Gaming Blog

Microgames, Monster Games, and Role Playing Games

The Lack of Ideological Diversity is Killing Comics

Okay, you’ve heard the refrain.

Guys like Ethan Van Sciver, Diversity & Comics, and Kasimir Urbanski all love to roast the more ludicrous efforts of the SJW’s within the comics scene. It makes for entertaining YouTube videos, that’s for sure. But Arkhaven comes onto the scene and suddenly they all want to run an angle on it claiming that these guys are just like the SJW’s except they’re just coming at from the opposite end of the political spectrum. Two sides of the same coin and all that.

Here’s why that’s wrong:

In the first place, the ideology the SJW’s are pushing is so incoherent, it isn’t really fair to characterize it with “politics”. And what they are injecting into the comics media is something fundamentally different from the way that, say, A Princess of Mars or Dune deal with political issues. Actual politics is really quite interesting– from the French and American revolutions to various civil wars throughout history… there’s a lot to it! But there really isn’t any substance to the SJW’s brand of so-called “politics”. There’s nothing to engage with. There’s nothing to have a conversation about. There’s no room for a different viewpoint on complex issues. There is only the opportunity for people signal their support for their freakish revolution as they tear down the cultural reference points of the people they seek to bully and humiliate.

Arkhaven is not doing anything remotely like that. In the first place, they are creating their own characters and settings rather than subverting longstanding icons of the field. And they’re doing it in such a way as to appeal to people that have been under-served by comics, movies, and publishing in general.

Ethan Van Sciver, Diversity & Comics, and Kasimir Urbanski have a particular narrow perspective on all this. It’s as if they would be content with the comics medium if only it were just a little bit less obnoxiously SJW. They are fine with the overall leftist tilt that could be taken for granted within the field throughout the eighties and nineties. And they are triggered at the idea of anyone violating the sort of boundaries and restrictions on expression that were laid down by the sort of people that take for granted that everyone on the right is necessarily boorish, déclassé, and hateful by definition.

But the problem with comics and media in general is that its creative palette has been artificially limited for so long, that people can’t even imagine what things were like when ideological diversity could be taken for granted as a given.

It’s time for that to change.

UPDATE: Kasimir Urbanski doubles down on the “Arkhaven is the mirror image of the SJWs” argument:

I don’t see what you guys are doing as creating “ideological diversity”. I have yet to see ANYTHING from the Alt-heroes previews that leads me to think that it will be even one micron more sophisticated in its propagandism for the ultra-reactionary Collectivist Right than, say, Ms.Marvel or She-Thor are shallow propagandism for the totalitarian Collectivist Left.

I want comics (and RPGs, video games, sci-fi, fantasy, film, novels and TV) that talk about politics, of any kind. I don’t want ANY of the above that are just PROPAGANDA.

My answer: People that would otherwise be systematically no-platformed by the left showing up, producing content, and reaching an audience by definition creates ideological diversity within the field.

 

4 responses to “The Lack of Ideological Diversity is Killing Comics

  1. natewinchester January 21, 2018 at 7:10 pm

    This is something I’ve ranted on multiple times before:
    https://natewinchester.wordpress.com/2017/08/21/keep-politics-out/

    There’s a difference between POLITICS (the interplay of people) vs ISSUES (modern day political points). Nothing will date a story faster than putting issues in it.

    Like I’ll point out that with all the green lantern call backs to the silver age, it is to the sci-fi, imaginative stuff of Alan Moore, not to anything like the panel pictured above.

  2. Pingback: Sensor Sweep: A. Merritt, Dungeons & Dragons, Monster Manuals, and the Murder of Sword and Sorcery – castaliahouse.com

  3. malcolmthecynic January 22, 2018 at 1:20 am

    As Vox Day correctly pointed out, all those guys can champion and create all the moderate comics they want…as long as guys like Vox Day are pushing back against the SJWs who would want to stop them.

    Equating the two is the equivalent of equating the guy who punches back to the bully that stuffed him into the locker in the first place. It’s the evil of Zero Tolerance Policy writ large.

  4. Bagger Vance January 23, 2018 at 4:42 pm

    I can only imagine the (not very bright) Pundit is thinking of some attempts made in the past, such as “Liberality for All” that amused the coastal elite a few years ago.
    https://scans-daily.dreamwidth.org/5518130.html

    But as one might say, “real” right-wing politics have never been tried. Look at how Ditko’s Objectivism has never been applied (positively) to superheroes, which would seem to be perfect for it. Or how his Question got defanged from said objectivism to some mushy ‘buddhism’ typical for the 80s.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: