Jeffro's Space Gaming Blog

Microgames, Monster Games, and Role Playing Games

The Jeffro Test

So Cory Doctorow has characterized myself and some of my associates as being upset “that science fiction [has] changed to reflect the world since the 1970s.” This is of course grossly unfair, and given the number of easily debunked assertions that he makes within the same paragraph I should probably just let this go right along with all the other libel that’s being amplified by megaphone types all across media outlets of late. I mean, what’s it to me if these people want to completely burn up their credibility to the same degree that Devin Wilson did last year?

But I do take umbrage at this sort of thing. I mean… at what point did it become cool to dump on the seventies? The seventies were awesome! There was no AIDS. No political correctness. No selfies. You had Genesis, The Police, Electric Light Orchestra, Pink Floyd, ZZ Top…. That was some seriously good stuff. And really, I know hatemongers like me aren’t supposed to admit it… but the Bee Gees weren’t that bad. You could turn on The Midnight Special and see The Cars or Cheap Trick playing live. You could turn on Sesame Street and hear Stevie Wonder doing an extended vamp on “Superstition”. Musicians could still build a career based on their ability to… you know… play music… not on how they looked. (That was done by the time Mr. Doctorow would be in high school, when Millie Vanillie was lip syncing and M. C. Hammer was dancing around to recycled music.)

So the seventies had more than a few redeeming qualities. But what about the science fiction? There’s all kinds of reasons why it might have been better back then, too. For starters, there was more money in it… not least because was still legal for the cigarette industry to prop up the magazines. And I know that for myself, I gradually drifted away from science fiction novels in general over the years. I could never quite put my finger on what had gone wrong… I just tended to do more with games or maybe just pick up an occasional masterwork like The Mote in God’s Eye or something. Now that the mask has come off in other domains it’s a lot easier to see what’s going on, though.

Take for instance the Bechdel Test, which gets a strange amount of attention lately:

The Bechdel test asks if a work of fiction features at least two women who talk to each other about something other than a man.

Now I know that whoever came up with that (someone named Bechdel maybe?) had a point they were trying to make and all… but seriously that has to be just about the least dramatic premise for a scene that I can think of. Now I’m too much of a nice guy to poke fun at someone else’s ditty. It’s enough for me to point out that the fact that it’s just not at all a selling point for me if a film or story that passes the Bechdel test. But it’s not cool to knock it without coming up with something that’s potentially better, so here’s mine:

The Jeffro Test: The work in question must include at least one scene where one man attempts to kill or otherwise beat down another man in single combat out of a combination of rage, hatred, and envy– especially over a loss of status, position, and (usually) the favor of a mind-numbingly hot superbabe.

Okay, now we’re talking! While this is not a sufficient test to determine whether or not a film is good or not, I have to say… it certainly seems to nail down the exact point when a good film becomes awesome. Here are some examples:

This scene from Back to the Future was positively epic. I remember seeing it in theaters and people actually cheered at the end of it. Just brilliant.

Superman II had a very similar moment:

That was the low point of the film, too. But when Superman flew up and said to General Zod, “would you care to step outside?” Ah, that was positively electric!

Now… this one’s more recent… and I’m not much for Masterpiece Theater, but even that show can get me on the edge of my seat when it makes a hearty effort to meet my standards:

Lord Grantham has noticed that this guy seems a bit overeager to spend time with Lady Grantham, but when he comes home early from an event to find the bad guy from Hudson Hawk chatting her up in his own bedroom, well… it’s about to get real!

Now you might at first think that this is some kind of a dude thing and the women in these scenarios are being treated like trophies, prizes, property or whatever. This is of course completely unfair to women… who so eat up the chance to be at the center of this sort of drama that they will even engineer this sort of thing on occasion:

However it happens, it is almost invariably entertaining. This is not some sort of edifying pro-social message by any stretch… and that is just fine with me. But then… something other than politics is my priority here, isn’t it?

Advertisements

16 responses to “The Jeffro Test

  1. Cirsova April 29, 2015 at 3:06 pm

    In fairness to the Bechdel test, people trying to use it as an actual thing are not getting the joke. The example used in the original comic of a movie passing the Bechdel test – Alien – (‘two women talk about… an alien’): the punchline was that it’s NOT a good test, even in crazy feminist women’s issues land.

    • jeffro April 29, 2015 at 3:16 pm

      Ha, so it’s literally a joke. You don’t get that in anything I’ve read about it. People invoking it generally act like it is SRS BSNS.

      • Cirsova April 29, 2015 at 3:25 pm

        It was a 25 year old lesbian joke that people actually started taking serious a few years ago, because in the course of those 25 years everyone lost their goddamn minds.

        If we go by Wikipedia source dates alone, IT’S CHARLIE FUCKING STROSS’s FAULT!

        That last panel: That is where they both realize how stupid the rule is. That is the part that no one ever talks about.

      • malcolmthecynic March 4, 2016 at 1:52 am

        Some google-fu indicates that the comic is mocking the test. Not the other way around.

  2. Pingback: All the European Vacations of Tracing One’s Ancestory in the Galaxy and She Had to Walk Into Mine | Cirsova

  3. Pingback: All the European Vacations of Tracing One’s Ancestry in the Galaxy and She Had to Walk Into Mine | Cirsova

  4. malcolmthecynic March 4, 2016 at 1:53 am

    And yes, it was created by Alison Bechdel, a feminist whose autobiography was made into an award-winning musical, as good an indicator of how low theater has sunk as any.

  5. Pingback: Short Reviews – Coming of the Gods by Chester Whitehorn – castaliahouse.com

  6. Pingback: Short Reviews – The Enchantress of Venus by Leigh Brackett – castaliahouse.com

  7. H.P. May 23, 2016 at 2:14 pm

    Another example is of course the best scene from The Princess Bride: Inigo finally confronting his father’s killer.

    • jeffro May 23, 2016 at 2:19 pm

      Great film. A good example of how these supposedly outdated tropes appeal to both boys and girls, men and women. Few films are that beloved.

  8. Pingback: The Best Movie Scene Ever – castaliahouse.com

  9. Jay DiNitto October 24, 2016 at 9:18 pm

    I have a similar test, though not nearly as precise as the Jeffro Test…concerning the victims of violence in a story.

    http://www.jaydinitto.com/the-jay-test/

  10. Pingback: Gardner Dozois on Fantasy’s Extinction Event – castaliahouse.com

  11. Pingback: REVIEW: Sudden Rescue by Jon Mollison – castaliahouse.com

  12. Pingback: SUPERVERSIVE Beginning of Blue SF: Edison’s Conquest of Mars – castaliahouse.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: